1. Home
  2. »
  3. Blog
  4. »
  5. FIRST Framework for Ethical and User Centric AI

Table of Contents

Ethical and User-centric AI

Ethical and User-centric AI

Ethical and User-centric AI

Introduction

The development of AI-powered products comes with significant responsibility. If not designed carefully, these products can lead to unintended consequences. Ensuring diversity in the datasets used for training AI models is crucial for unbiased behavior in AI products.

Here are a few examples that have resulted in biased behavior:

Amazon’s Recruitment Tool

Amazon developed an AI-powered recruitment tool that favored male candidates over female candidates for technical job roles. This bias occurred because the tool was trained on resumes predominantly submitted by men over a ten-year period.

https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKCN1MK0AG

Google’s Photo Classification Tool

The AI algorithm used by Google Photos mistakenly classified photos of Black individuals as “gorillas,” an offensive and racist error. This incident underscores significant racial bias in image recognition services, which were trained using only images of white individuals.

https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-33347866

COMPAS Recidivism Algorithm

The US courts utilized the COMPAS Recidivism algorithm to assess the likelihood of a defendant reoffending. The tool was found to be biased against African-Americans, inaccurately predicting that Black defendants were more likely to reoffend compared to white defendants.

https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessments-in-criminal-sentencing

Various Facial Recognition Tools

Research at MIT Media Lab led by Joy Buolamwini demonstrated that facial recognition technologies from various top tech companies like IBM and Microsoft had high error rates in identifying the gender of women and dark-skinned individuals, indicating strong bias due to datasets composed predominantly of lighter-skinned males.

https://proceedings.mlr.press/v81/buolamwini18a/buolamwini18a.pdf

To address bias in Artificial Intelligence models, I propose a User and Ethical Centric “FIRST” framework for AI. This framework highlights five key principles: Feedback mechanisms, Integrity testing of datasets, Regular ethical reviews, Stakeholder inclusion, and Transparency. Each element plays a crucial role in developing AI systems that are not only user-centric but also ethically responsible.

Feedback Mechanisms (F):

A robust feedback mechanism is fundamental to the FIRST framework and should be established at the beginning of product development. Gathering diverse feedback from developers and testers before wider release is essential. Features that enable users to report issues, such as biases and inaccuracies, are critical. Clearly defined channels allow users to contribute actively to the development of better AI products, ensuring their voices influence the final outcomes that the meet real-world needs.

Integrity Testing of datasets (I):

The second crucial step is selecting datasets that maintain the ethical integrity of AI products. Always perform a comprehensive check against various segments to ensure AI fairness, including:

    1. Socio-economic Status

    1. Political Views

    1. Disability

    1. Age

    1. Gender and Sex

    1. Sexual Orientation

    1. Ethnicity and Race

    1. Geographical Location

    1. Language and Dialect

    1. Religion

    1. Caste

    1. Cuss words

Rigorous testing for biases against these segments ensures the AI remains equitable and leads to better dataset selection.

Regular Ethical Reviews (R):

AI product developers should conduct regular ethical reviews, incorporating feedback and results from Integrity Testing. This process aids in identifying biases early on, allowing for corrections before releasing the product to a wider audience, thus mitigating ethical scrutiny from users, the press, and the governments. Consistent reviews enable continuous improvement of AI products and adherence to the highest ethical standards in response to changing societal norms.

Stakeholder Inclusion (S):

AI products should prioritize intended stakeholders at all times. The AI must generate content that is sensitive to user sentiments and capable of influencing opinions and decisions. Including diverse perspectives from the start ensures that the final product is embraced by all intended users. Introducing roles such as Chief Ethical Advisor (CEA) may help ensure the product’s success without backlash.

Transparency (T):

Finally, it is fundamental to inform stakeholders about the operations of AI systems and the data collection and usage. Users deserve clear, concise information on how their data is collected, handled, and protected. Building trust through adherence to regulations like GDPR, CCPA, and HIPAA is essential. When users understand the use of their data and the protective measures in place, their confidence in AI systems grows, leading to the success of the AI products.

Final Thoughts

By adopting the FIRST framework, organizations can develop AI-powered products with ethical integrity and a user-centric approach. This enhances not only the quality and reliability of AI applications but also fosters a trustworthy relationship between technology providers and the public. Such a framework represents a commitment to the sustainable and ethical advancement of AI technology.